First of all, this is not a paid review. It’s in preparation for a series of articles, Making Money with Mini Sites, Step by Step, that I’m going to start tomorrow. I will use 19 Pages for this series so I thought I’d review it first so you can see what it can and can’t do.
What it is
19 Pages is a very simple CMS built for fast deployment of mini sites by the guys from 45n5. It’s limited to 20 pages, index plus 19 articles, because that’s how the creators see mini sites, having 20 pages or less.
Here’s the short presentation/tutorial video from 19Pages.
The Good Parts
Simple to install - It doesn’t need a database, because it stores everything in its files. You just unzip the files and upload them to your host, and you’re ready to go. Log in (user: admin, password: admin), change the password (!) and start writing.
Easy to move - its as simple as moving the files from a host to another
Extremely easy to use - you don’t really have that many options to play with. You write the text, add the meta description and keywords and you’re done.
SEO OK for the most part - I would’ve preferred using - instead of _ for url’s but they’re still SE friendly. You probably can modify these in the .htaccess, but I’m not that technical so no idea there. You can add meta description and keywords so that’s covered too. No need to install SEO plugins like you would with WordPress. The only problem in the SEO department is that not all templates are coded well when it comes to the page title. The default version is ok, but the Made Of Cheese template uses the title from the index on all the pages, instead of using the article title. Didn’t check all the templates to see if there are others with this problem. I hope they fix this for the next release.
Until then, click Edit template and then at the top, in the head section, replace the part marked with red
<title><?php echo $sitename;?></title>
with this: $sitetitle;?
The Bad Parts
These are experienced by me with an older version. No idea if they fixed them yet.
- Deleting the site leaves some sort of traces on the server. I added an index.html and it still kept saying that it couldn’t find the index.php
- On the domain where I used it I had two directories /blog and /forums. The blog worked fine, but I couldn’t access the forums anymore. It took me to a 404 page of the CMS as far as I can remember.
- Doesn’t work in folders, only on sub-domains or on the main domain. So test.example.com and example.com work fine, but example.com/test doesn’t work. Shouldn’t be a problem because most people don’t install mini sites in folders. I imagine it doesn’t work there because of the .htaccess file? Not sure.
- It’s got a limited number of templates to use. They offer custom templates for $49 but that’s too high if you want to have a template fit for a certain niche. If you want a template to use on all your mini sites it might be worth it. If you know how to code I assume you can make one yourself.
Conclusions
All in all, I like it. I like it a lot. It’s supposed to be easy and for mini sites only and it does that well. Extremely easy to use and deploy. I used WordPress for static sites until recently, but I’ll switch to 19Pages for any mini sites I’ll make from now on.
Tomorrow or the day after tomorrow I’ll start the Making Money with Mini Sites, Step by Step series. The first article in the series will be rather long because it will detail every step, so I might not be able to finish it tomorrow.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed.!



45n5 responded on 31 Aug 2007 at 4:14 am #
wow, very cool review
email me when the series is over and I can add you a link from the 19pages site.
also, “Deleting the site leaves some sort of traces on the server.”
your ftp software isn’t removing the .htaccess file, make sure “hidden” files are shown. justa guess
thanks,
mark
Alexandru responded on 31 Aug 2007 at 4:28 am #
My pleasure Mark
I’ve been looking for a long time for this kind of CMS. Drove me nuts upgrading WordPress installs from a bunch of mini-sites because security bugs appeared and I couldn’t risk leaving them like that.
And thanks for the .htaccess tip. Didn’t realize it was still there.
Peter Burkes responded on 15 Sep 2007 at 2:33 am #
If fount a solution to the root-problem on
http://www.namepros.com/for-sale-advertising-board/306435-19pages-free-minisite-builder.html
Greetings from Germany
Alexandru responded on 15 Sep 2007 at 5:35 am #
That’s great! I’ll try it out for my next mini-site. Thanks for pointing it out
Toby Gibbs responded on 18 Apr 2008 at 6:34 am #
aulophyte gulfy antipathida essang dayward protopodial unearnest timetaker
Astro Optics Pvt. Ltd.
http://studiosound.planethalflife.gamespy.com/
Lakshmi responded on 04 May 2008 at 6:32 am #
It looks like a good idea. But I am sure now a days many even small websites looking for 100s of pages for CMS. Don’t know how this will be supported here.